DOPPLER CIRCLE

Han Erim

Independent Researcher

November 13, 2026

DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.24163631


1. What is Doppler Circle?

Doppler Circle is a model developed within the framework of Alice Law to examine geometrically the mutual exchange of signals between two systems in circular motion. Its English name is Doppler Circle.

This study extends the signal exchange examined in Doppler Quadrilateral to circular motion. Whereas the aircraft in Doppler Quadrilateral follow straight paths, those in Doppler Circle travel along circular arcs. This allows the effects of a continuously changing direction of motion on signal routes and wavelengths to be examined.

In accordance with the (c+v) (c−v) mathematics of Alice Law, the animation is based on the assumption that a signal travels at speed c relative to the reference frame of its destination target. The signal movements and numerical values shown in the animation are calculated according to the rules of this model.

Two aircraft represent the two moving systems. Each aircraft both sends signals and receives signals from the other. Users can change the initial and arrival positions and the acceleration and deceleration settings, then examine the resulting geometric relationships using auxiliary drawings and numerical data.

Incorporating accelerated motion into Alice Law is a major leap forward.

How to incorporate accelerated motion into Alice Law was one of the central questions I had been considering for 25 years. With this series of studies, accelerated motion has been included within the scope of Alice Law, taking its (c+v) (c−v) mathematics to a more advanced stage. The Doppler Circle animation is an example of this advance applied to circular motion, allowing calculations and step-by-step examination.

This extension rests on the following assumption: Even when the target undergoes accelerated motion, the signal travels at speed c relative to the reference frame of its destination target. The target speeding up, slowing down or changing direction during the signal’s journey does not change this rule. Signal motion in the animation is calculated using the target’s changing position so that this condition is satisfied.

I would like to note that, in my research, I have not found sufficient, reliable experimental data suitable for directly testing this assumption. Nor have I encountered an experimental finding that contradicts it.

The Doppler Circle animation appears immediately below. Explanations and instructions for using it are provided beneath the animation.

My other studies, Doppler Quadrilateral, which examines linear motion, and Doppler Any Path, which covers different curved paths, were published at the same time as this work.

flash 1

2. What do points A, B, C and D represent?

The first aircraft moves from A to B and the second from C to D, following arcs of the circle. A and C are the aircraft positions when the first signals are emitted; B and D are their positions when those signals reach their targets.

These points are not necessarily places where the aircraft start moving or must stop upon arrival. The aircraft may already be moving before reaching A and C and may continue moving beyond B and D. The animation shows the portion of their motion between the emission and reception of the first signals.

Point Meaning
A Position of the first aircraft when the first signals are emitted
B Position of the first aircraft when the first signals arrive
C Position of the second aircraft when the first signals are emitted
D Position of the second aircraft when the first signals arrive

Motion arcs and reference lines

The line segments AB and CD are not the paths traveled by the aircraft. They are chords connecting the initial and arrival points. The aircraft travel along the selected circular arcs between these points. When evaluating the distance traveled, distinguish between chord length and arc length.

Motion is calculated along the shorter arc between the initial and arrival points. When repositioning the points, note that the selected arc and direction of motion may also change.

Here, AC is the straight-line distance between A and C, not the length of a circular arc. The travel time of the first signals is calculated using this distance: t₀ = AC / c.

Points A, B, C and D and the center of the circle are fixed relative to the ground reference frame within the selected arrangement. The aircraft’s positions and movements are shown in that frame. Auxiliary signal routes drawn relative to the receiver or sender move with the corresponding aircraft.

Diagonals and signal routes

AD and CB are line segments connecting the emission and arrival points of the first signals. In circular motion, the signal routes relative to the ground may be curved even when the aircraft’s speeds are constant. These line segments therefore do not represent the signals’ entire journeys.

Changing the geometry

Reposition the control points to change the motion arcs, the initial separation and the aircraft’s directions of travel. Changing AC also changes the total duration. Changing the arc length to be traveled in the same time changes the aircraft’s average speed.

Changing only the acceleration percentage leaves the selected path, initial and arrival points, and total duration unchanged. What changes is where the aircraft is along the arc at each instant.

3. First signals and the duration of the animation


Doppler Quadrilaterals are specific to individual signals. Since the defining events are a signal’s emission and its arrival at its target, each Doppler Quadrilateral belongs to the emitted signal in question. As the emission and arrival positions change for each successive signal, a different Doppler Quadrilateral applies.


In Doppler Circle, the main quadrilateral defined by A, B, C and D belongs to the first two signals sent in opposite directions at the very start of the animation. When Signal Marker is enabled (as it is by default), these signals can be followed using flashing markers.


Why do the first signals arrive simultaneously?

According to Alice Law, each signal travels at speed c relative to the reference frame of its destination target. At the moment the first signals are emitted, the distance between the aircraft is AC. Each signal therefore covers this distance at speed c in its own target’s reference frame, giving both signals the same travel time:

t₀ = AC / c


The first signals, emitted simultaneously, reach their targets simultaneously after equal travel times. At that moment, the first aircraft reaches B and the second reaches D.

Enable Incoming Signal Route for both aircraft. You can then follow the first signals as they travel at speed c along routes of length AC, each in the reference frame of its own receiving aircraft.


What time interval does Motion Control show?

The signal travel time t₀ determines the duration of the aircraft’s motion shown in the animation. If the start of Motion Control is denoted by t₁ and its end by t₂, the duration is t₀ = t₂ − t₁. Move the slider forward or backward to examine any instant between the emission of the first signals and their arrival at their targets.


Signals emitted later

The aircraft continue emitting signals throughout their motion. Because their positions change for later emissions, the emission and arrival positions must be considered separately for each new signal exchange. These emissions can also be assigned their own Doppler Quadrilaterals.

Thus, the main quadrilateral on screen is not shared by all emissions; it shows the emission and arrival geometry of the first signals.

4. Sine wave, wavelength and speed scale

A sine wave is used to make regular signal emissions and wavelength changes visible. The progression from 0° to 360° is one complete cycle. The interval between two successive positions at the same phase, spanning one complete wave, represents the wavelength.

The unchanged reference wavelength in the animation is set to λ₀ = 20 px. This value defines the emission pattern and provides a reference for comparing calculated wavelengths. Depending on the selected route, speed and acceleration, Doppler shift occurs in the emitted signals; the length of every wave displayed should therefore not be expected to remain 20 px.

With a suitable emission arrangement, the positions of emitted signals at a particular instant can be arranged in a sinusoidal pattern similar to the animation. However, the sine drawing here illustrates signal phase and wavelength changes, rather than the design of such a device. Use Signal Path to display the centerline of propagation.

Speeds in the animation are expressed relative to c. For example, 0.5 c is half the speed of light. Lengths are displayed in pixels (px). The start of the motion slider corresponds to t₁, when the first signals are emitted; its end corresponds to t₂, when they reach their targets.

5. Circular motion at constant and varying speeds

Each aircraft’s acceleration and deceleration settings are independent. One aircraft may travel around the circle at constant speed while the other speeds up or slows down. The lock control lets you adjust both aircraft’s acceleration percentages together.

At an acceleration percentage of 0%, motion along the circle is at constant speed. The aircraft covers equal arc lengths in equal time intervals. Its direction of motion, however, changes continuously. Constant speed therefore does not imply a constant velocity vector or the absence of physical acceleration.

The acceleration control here determines whether the speed increases or decreases. The centripetal acceleration associated with the changing direction of circular motion is present even when the control is set to 0%.

Increasing the percentage increases the effect of the selected Acceleration or Deceleration setting. This changes neither the total duration nor the motion arc; it changes how the same arc is traveled in the same time.

For example, at 50% on a circle, with Acceleration selected, the initial speed is half the average speed and the final speed is one and a half times the average speed. With Deceleration selected, these values are reversed. This percentage is a ratio that determines the motion profile, not a direct acceleration value in m/s².

This explanation of constant speed applies to circular geometry. If different horizontal and vertical radii are selected to create an ellipse, equal angular increments do not correspond to equal distances traveled. In the current calculation, the 0% setting does not guarantee constant speed along an ellipse.

6. How is Doppler shift calculated?


In the animation, Doppler shift is calculated from distance measurements taken at signal emission for two consecutive complete wave cycles. Both emissions correspond to the same phase of the sine wave: 0°.

Sequence of events:

  1. When the first signal is emitted, the distance between the sending aircraft and the target aircraft is measured. This value is called R₁.
  2. The emitted signal begins traveling toward its target at speed c along its own Incoming Signal Route.
  3. One complete cycle later, the second signal is emitted. The distance measured at this second emission is called R₂.
  4. The wavelength between these emissions is calculated by taking the difference between the two signals’ remaining distances to the target at the same instant.

How far does the first signal travel between emissions?

The reference wavelength is λ₀ = 20 px. Since the signal travels at speed c relative to its target in this model, the first signal’s remaining distance to the target decreases by 20 px during one complete cycle.

Therefore, when the second signal is emitted:

The difference between these two remaining distances gives the wavelength calculated for the corresponding emission interval:

λ′ = R₂ − (R₁ − 20)


In other words:

λ′ = 20 + R₂ − R₁

In general form:

λ′ = λ₀ + (R₂ − R₁)


Example

Suppose the distance between the aircraft is 100 px at the first emission and 103 px at the second.

When the second signal is emitted, the first signal’s remaining distance is 100 − 20 = 80 px. Since the second signal is 103 px from the target:
λ′ = 103 − 80 = 23 px


With a reference wavelength of 20 px, the wavelength has therefore increased by 3 px over this emission interval.

Change in distance between emissions Calculated wavelength
Distance increases by 3 px 23 px — lengthening
Distance remains unchanged 20 px — no change
Distance decreases by 3 px 17 px — shortening


What does the Doppler Shift table show?

This calculation is repeated for successive complete wave cycles. Enabling Doppler Shift displays the wavelengths calculated for the corresponding emission intervals.


If the distance between the aircraft changes by the same amount each cycle, the calculated values remain the same. If this change varies because of the motion geometry or acceleration, the values vary as well.


The quantity compared here is the difference between the two signals’ remaining distances to the target at the same instant. When their arrival directions differ, this must not be confused with the straight-line distance between the two signal markers on screen.


In the animation’s wavelength display, the number above the dashed line shows the average wavelength calculated from the initial and final geometry, in pixels. The distance between the aircraft is AC when the first signals are emitted and BD when those signals reach their targets. The initial distance contains AC / 20 reference wavelengths. Dividing the final distance by this number gives BD / (AC / 20).

Each row below the line shows the wavelength calculated for a pair of successive emissions. The value above the line depends only on AC and BD. As long as these distances stay fixed, moving the time slider leaves that value unchanged.


Following the calculation geometrically


Enable Signal Routes 1, Signal Routes 2 and Wave Markers to see the routes of signals emitted at phase 0° and their positions along these routes. The wavelength calculation compares the remaining distances to the target at the same instant for two successive signals traveling along these routes. This lets you follow the calculation above directly in the drawing.

7. The difference between Signal Path and Signal Route

Signal Path is the centerline formed by the positions, at a selected instant, of signal portions emitted at different times. Signal Route is the trajectory followed by one particular signal over time. The first describes the wave sequence at one instant; the second describes an individual signal’s journey.

The same signal’s motion may look different relative to the ground, the sending aircraft or the receiving aircraft. Each auxiliary drawing should therefore be interpreted in its corresponding reference frame.

Incoming Signal Route shows the first signal’s route relative to the receiving aircraft. In this model, the route for the first signal is parallel to AC and has length AC. The auxiliary drawing moves with the receiving aircraft as it follows its circular path. This receiver-based representation uses axes that translate with the receiver, rather than cockpit axes that rotate with the aircraft’s heading.

Outgoing Signal Route shows the first signal’s route relative to the sending aircraft. In circular motion, this route may be curved even at constant speeds. Its shape depends on the motion of both the sender and the receiver. The line BD provides a reference for the emission and arrival geometry; it does not represent the entire route by itself.

Reference Route is the first signal route calculated between the same initial and arrival points without applying the speeding-up or slowing-down effect. For circular geometry, it corresponds to the aircraft moving at constant speeds. It is drawn relative to the ground and may be curved because of the circular motion.

Real Route shows the first signal’s route relative to the ground under the selected acceleration and deceleration settings. For circular geometry, it coincides with Reference Route when both aircraft’s acceleration percentages are 0%.

8. Using the controls

Motion Control

The slider below the animation displays the motion over the duration determined by t₀ = AC / c. Move it forward or backward to examine different instants. When you stop dragging it, the aircraft positions, signals and numerical values for that instant are displayed.

Display options for each aircraft

Each aircraft has its own group of options. Use the relevant group to show or hide the drawings associated with that system.

Signal Marker: Shows the first signal emitted at the start of the animation. Follow the flashing marker to track its position.

Signal Path: Shows the centerline formed by the positions of successive emissions at the selected instant.

Sine Wave: Displays the emitted wave sequence as a sine curve, allowing wavelength changes to be examined visually.

Wave Markers: Mark the zero crossings at the same phase (0°) of each complete sine-wave cycle with green points. Successive markers help you follow the wave cycles and their distribution on screen.

Incoming Signal Route: Shows the first signal’s route relative to the receiving aircraft.

Outgoing Signal Route: Shows the first signal’s route relative to the sending aircraft.

Draw Arc: Displays the auxiliary arcs and O1/O2 points used for geometric comparisons. These auxiliary drawings should not be confused with the motion arcs followed by the aircraft from A to B and from C to D.

Reference Route: Shows the first signal route calculated without applying the speeding-up or slowing-down effect. This route may be curved even when the aircraft travel at constant speeds along the circle.

Real Route: Shows the first signal route calculated under the selected acceleration conditions.

Doppler shift and auxiliary drawings

Doppler Shift: Displays the values calculated by adding the reference wavelength of 20 px to the difference between the source–target distances measured at two consecutive emissions. Section 6 explains how the values in the Doppler Shift table are calculated.

Equal Phase Lines: Connect the two aircraft’s positions at the start of each complete wave cycle. Each line represents both aircraft’s positions at the same emission instant. Compare the distances traveled along the motion arc between the endpoints of successive lines. On a circle, equal distances indicate constant speed; increasing distances indicate acceleration, and decreasing distances indicate deceleration. The gaps between the middle portions of the lines are not, by themselves, a measure of speed. The drawings cover the full duration of the animation, so calculated positions beyond the selected instant are also visible.

Signal Routes 1: For emissions from the first aircraft at the start of complete wave cycles, shows the directions connecting the two aircraft’s positions at each emission instant in the second aircraft’s reference frame. The arrival directions of different emissions can thus be examined together. Use this option with Wave Markers.

Signal Routes 2: Provides the corresponding display for the second aircraft’s emissions in the first aircraft’s reference frame. These two options show auxiliary directions for different emission instants together; the lines do not represent successive positions of a single signal over time. Use this option with Wave Markers.


Geometry and numerical information

Distances: Shows the lengths and auxiliary dimension lines used in the quadrilateral.

Equalities: Displays mathematical expressions for the geometric lengths. Use this display together with Distances.

Edge Labels: Displays the names of the sides and auxiliary lines.

Image Objects: Geometrically shows where an observer in the receiving aircraft would see the other aircraft when the first signal arrives. The observer sees the aircraft’s “image object” at the opposite end of the Incoming Signal Route. These aircraft images are colored green to avoid confusion. When enabling Image Objects, also enable Incoming Signal Route for both aircraft.

Acceleration Control

Acceleration: Makes the selected aircraft’s speed increase throughout the motion.

Deceleration: Makes the selected aircraft’s speed decrease throughout the motion.

Acceleration Percentage: Determines how speed increases or decreases during the motion. On a circle, 0% represents constant speed; it does not eliminate the centripetal acceleration caused by the change in direction. The two aircraft can be adjusted independently.


Lock: Lets you adjust the two aircraft’s acceleration percentages together while keeping them equal.

9. Settings and Data windows

Settings window

The Settings button opens a window where you can change the angular positions of A, B, C and D, the horizontal and vertical radii, and the angle display convention.

Angular positions of the points: Each point has a slider and a numerical field. These controls update the same value together. Changing the angle moves the corresponding point along the circle or ellipse. A and B determine the first aircraft’s initial and arrival positions; C and D determine those of the second aircraft.

UI Coordinates and Flash Coordinates

These two options change the reference direction for angles and how they are displayed. Switching between them does not move the points or change the motion arrangement. In both conventions, positive angles run clockwise on screen.

Direction UI Coordinates Flash Coordinates
Up 0° 270°
Right 90° 0°
Down 180° or −180° 90°
Left −90° 180°

UI Coordinates: Angles are displayed in the range −180° to 180°, with 0° pointing upward.

Flash Coordinates: 0° points to the right. Negative internal angle values are displayed with 360° added; for example, −90° appears as 270°. The internal range of both the slider and the numerical control remains −180° to 180°; you can use the slider to select directions displayed above 180°.

Horizontal and vertical radii

Horizontal radius: Sets the half-width from the center to the right or left. It can be adjusted from 200 to 450 px in 1 px steps.


Vertical radius: Sets the half-height from the center upward or downward. It can be adjusted from 150 to 330 px in 1 px steps. You can also adjust angles and radii by entering values directly into the numerical fields.

Equal radii produce a circle; different radii produce an ellipse. In the initial arrangement, both are 280 px. On an ellipse, the angle is a parameter that positions the point together with the horizontal and vertical radii; it is not everywhere equal to the geometric angle of the line from the center to the point. Section 5 explains why the 0% acceleration setting does not guarantee constant speed along an ellipse.

Swapping points and Triangle Mode

A ↔ B: Swaps the first aircraft’s initial and arrival points. Under ordinary conditions, this reverses the direction of motion along the same shorter arc.

C ↔ D: Swaps the second aircraft’s initial and arrival points. Under ordinary conditions, this reverses the direction of motion along the same shorter arc.

Since these operations also change where the first signals are emitted, the distance AC and the total duration of motion may change.

Triangle Mode: When enabled, a stationary antenna replaces the first aircraft, and A and B coincide. The second aircraft follows the arc from C to D. “Triangle” refers to the three distinct position points; the motion paths and signal routes need not all be straight. Disabling this option returns to the two-aircraft Doppler Circle arrangement. Switching modes loads the corresponding preset point arrangement.

Close: Closes the Settings window.

Data window

The Data button opens a window displaying numerical information for the selected instant. The information updates when you change Motion Control or other settings. When evaluating geometric lengths, distinguish between the straight-line distance between two points and the distance traveled by an aircraft along an arc.

10. Suggested sequence for an initial exploration

  1. Set both aircraft’s acceleration percentages to 0%. Examine constant-speed motion along the circle. Notice how the aircraft’s directions change as they move.
  2. Enable Signal Marker, Reference Route and Incoming Signal Route. Move Motion Control to the start and observe the aircraft’s positions at A and C.
  3. Slowly move Motion Control to the end. Follow the aircraft along their arcs to B and D as the first signals reach their targets.
  4. Examine Reference Route. Observe that the signal’s route relative to the ground can be curved even when the acceleration control is set to 0%.
  5. Enable Sine Wave and Wave Markers. Compare the positions, at the selected instant, of signals emitted at different times.
  6. Enable Doppler Shift. Compare the calculated wavelengths with 20 px. Examine how the distance between the aircraft changes between emissions.
  7. Enable Equal Phase Lines and apply acceleration to one aircraft. Compare the spacing of the marked positions along its motion arc.
  8. Enable Reference Route and Real Route together. Observe how changes in speed affect the signal route.
  9. Examine Incoming Signal Route and Outgoing Signal Route. Compare the representations of the same signal relative to the receiver, sender and ground. Use Distances, Equalities and Data to examine the numerical relationships.
  10. Switch to Doppler Triangle mode. Examine the effects of circular motion in one system while the other remains stationary.

Changing only one setting in each trial makes it easier to identify which effect causes the difference you observe.